Haskell on Arch Linux

I was a happy user of Ubuntu until a few months ago when GHC 6.10 was released. Ubuntu still had GHC 6.8.2. Posts on haskell-cafe told that Arch Linux had support for latest GHC, and support for over 700 Haskell libraries. Since I had started using Haskell for a few projects, I decided ot check Arch linux out. After a long weekend of struggling through the installation and learning more about linux than I intended to know, I had all my usual programs up and running on Arch. Once I discovered AUR, I had the latest versions of almost everything. Or so I thought.

The first glitch was that Arch does not install the profiling version of the libraries. I asked around on #haskell, and I was told, that I should use cabal to install the profiling version of libraries. I did not want to have conflicting versions of libraries, so I uninstalled a few libs from the Arch repositories, and manually installed them using cabal.

And now I figured out that Haskell libraries are not so up-to-date on AUR. For example, new versions of monte-carlo and gsl-random were released more than a week ago, but AUR still has the old versions. So, I decided to install them using cabal.

After having used Arch for about two months, I am not convinced that it has a good support for Haskell. The only good thing is that it comes with a version of cabal that can upgrade itself. (From what I remember, the ubuntu version of cabal could not upgrade  itself, and I had to install cabal by hand). But once cabal is updated, it is much more convenient to use cabal than the Arch repositories. Arch is a great distribution and I  like the rolling release philosophy, but its support for Haskell is mediocre at best.

Most programming languages come with their own tools for installing libraries (CPAN for perl, gem for ruby, cabal for Haskell, and now even texlive has a tool for updating packages). I do not think that it is worth the effort to port packages to distribution repositories. Simply using the language’s tool for installing libraries is much simpler and much easier to maintain.

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Haskell on Arch Linux

  1. Interesting. Thanks for the comments.

    For what its worth, AUR is no more than 2 weeks out of date, and we use cabal2arch to resync regularly (things are a bit behind due to the vacation break).

    The most important thing, of course, is that we have those packages — which means we can produce binaries for apps that use them, without hassle.

    If you’re a developer though, cabal-install is probably more useful than waiting for me to run cabal2arch for you.

    Cheers.

  2. Don: I do appreciate all the work that you do for making Haskell more easily accessible. It is just that I am a bit impatient 🙂

  3. Oh, the other reason we packages things natively is that the packages correctly resolve C library dependencies to the native C library used.

    This makes the packages with FFI bindings more reliable in native form, than cabal-install form.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s